Elgin Marbles – Coursework Example
Elgin Marbles Introduction In view of the fact that the Elgin marbles origin is Greece, they should bereturned to the rightful owner. The truth is that the Ottomans had no right to sell them to Lord Elgin since the marbles were not theirs. The British argues that they are protecting the marbles in their museum something Greece could not have done. This is due to the fact that, the marbles were excessively damaged while in Parthenon. However, this should not be an excuse because Greece has already constructed a world-class museum where it can display and protect them. Also, when the British government bought them from Lord Elgin it should have known that it was purchasing stolen goods. Though it is said that the marbles were bought for educational purposes, it does not make sense at all since the motive is not right. What is learnt from this act is that to preserve artifacts and history the law must be broken (James, 2004).
On the other hand, the British government’s efforts should not go unrewarded but this does not mean that it should keep the stolen artifacts in its museum. In addition, though both the British and Greece have good political argument, it should be left for the people to decide since it the people who possess a greater power. Personally, I believe that Greece is now capable of taking care of them as they represent their culture and history. They should let go of the past given that these are very delicate artifacts it is common knowledge that the Greeks would take good care of them (James, 2004).
In conclusion, by having the British retaining the Elgin marbles, it will be a bad example of the government’s deeds and it is no way an educative message. Measures should be taken to return the stolen artifacts to the rightful owner if the British government wants to fulfill the rationale of the purchase for “educational purposes.” The lesson learnt from the Elgin marbles is far much superior to art and history but it concerns morals, ethics and dignity.
James Bregman (2004). The real story of the Elgin Marbles: BBC News Online entertainment staff. Retrieved September 10, 2012 from