Ethics And Trust In Critical Thinking Decisions – Coursework Example
Ethics and Trust in Decisions The listed sources I would place in the following position, starting with the most trustworthy and ending with the least: social media; close friend; associate from work; dealer’s website; a salesman. In analyzing the credibility of the available sources of information, I would turn my attention at the degree of objectivity each of them can offer as well as competence of people I am talking to.
Namely, I would rather believe a conclusion about a product found in social media as this is a place where people share their own experience and express personal opinion, so I could weigh all the pros and cons and feel like I have made my personal, well-thought decision. In contrast, a salesman, whose goal is to sell a car would win little trust. Although he may have sufficient expert knowledge, I am prone to thinking that he may give biased information.
Influential by evaluating the level of trust in information provided by a close friend and an associate from work would be the degree of their awareness and knowledge in a given field. Therefore, even in case I am confident that a friend has no intention of deluding me, I may be skeptical to what he/she is saying if I know that my friend is not an expert. As for the dealer’s website, for me, it would be more plausible than a salesman, but less – than a social media site. Here, I would evaluate a design of a site and a tone in which the information is presented.
Thoroughly mulled over the question, I think that the decision of whether to slant an information or not would depend on the context and on the importance of my persuasion. I could slant information if I knew that some fatal mistake would occur if my interlocutor does not accept my position. In contrast, I would not do it if the issue is not critical.
My position reflects an ethical dilemma that can occur in case a person believes that it would bring more benefits in case another one accepts the position. However, slanting information leads to the person not seeing the full picture and not being able to evaluate all the details. Thereof, a dilemma is whether to strive for ensuring the common good or remaining trustful. For my interlocutor, the ethical problem can occur in case my attempt to slant information is revealed and he/she would have to decide whether I should be blamed for it and whether this fact undermines everything I was trying to persuade earlier.